Personal Critique of Textile Degree Shows 2017

Personal Critique of Textile Degree Shows 2017

Name of Degree Show student: Georgia Reece
Critique /comment on the development of ideas and concepts in this work:
The link between the bleeding colours in the background with the flowing lines layered on top works really well. I think the idea of combining man and nature is clever, and has been presented well in the textile pieces. You can see that the process of doing drawings based on minerals and the built environment has developed into a successful collection of final pieces.

How successfully are the materials and techniques used to convey the concepts?
The merging colours used represent the idea of nature and minerals well. It reminds me of the sea, especially with the silver lines on top, like waves. The silver in the lines could also link to the idea of the built environment, eg: big steel structures in cities. The background is soft and flowing like nature, whereas the lines on top are clear and precise like man made objects.

What is it about this exhibition that most impresses you?
The overall look of the collection is extremely professional and it all links together well. It stands out for me in terms of style, I love the colours and all of the samples are beautiful. I found this exhibition really inspiring and hope that I can achieve something as successful as this!

Briefly evaluate the presentation style of the work:
The work was presented really neatly and it draws you in to get close and look at the detail in the pieces. The variety of pieces to look at made it interesting.

 

Name of Degree Show student: Melissa Macdonald
Critique/ comment on the development of ideas and concepts in this work:
The collection reflects the concept of well being and is lovely as a group of work. The colours represent calmness and work well together to reflect the concept. I think the variety of different pieces like including ceramics really provides the feel of a cohesive home wear collection. It shows the possibilities for uses of the surface pattern designs.

How successfully are the materials and techniques used to convey the concepts?
The colours and use of shapes reflect the inspiration of Kew Gardens well. The patterns look lovely together as a collection and are aesthetically pleasing. The natural forms in the designs reflect the idea of well being described in the concept.

What is it about this exhibition that most impresses you?
The collection as a whole is wonderful together, with so many different products you get a great sense of how it would feel to be in a home environment with the designs in. I think the overall look of it is extremely professional and all of the designs are lovely. I really love the addition of the ceramics!

Briefly evaluate the presentation style of the work:
The work has been presented in a professional way and works really well as a collection. It creates an atmosphere of being in the home, you can visualise how the pieces would look in a real life home environment.

 

How do you perceive the shows, generally?
I found the show really inspiring to see. All of the work is so unique and professional, I can’t wait to be at the same stage in my 3rd year. It was really enjoyable to walk around and see everything.

List 3 key things you have learnt from what you have seen overall?
1. A fully developed and explored concept can produce amazing results.
2. Creating a collection with a whole variety of products like wallpaper, chairs, cushions, ceramics, stationery etc can really show off a successful design idea.
3. There are endless possibilities of what you can create for textiles, with so many different inspirations and products to look for.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s